The Fractures Within: The Subclassification, the Yard Stick Problem and the Constitutional Ambiguities of State of Punjab v Davinder Singh
Introduction The Madiga community of Andhra Pradesh has been sitting at the lowest rung of a society already at the bottom of the caste hierarchy for decades. Denied not just the dignity promised by the Constitution of India to all of its people but even the reservation meant specifically for them as a partial remedy. The underlying problem in their case was never that provisions of reservations did not exist, instead the issue was that a relatively more advanced Scheduled Ca
Pragati Singh
Oct 18
Analysing the Delimitation Bill 2026: A Missed Opportunity for Constitutional Reform
Introduction From a word unbeknownst to all to being the most controversial constitutional topic in 2026, the delimitation of electoral constituencies took centre stage in the Indian Parliament when the Union Government proposed the Constitution (One Hundred and Thirty-First) Amendment Bill 2026 (‘Amendment Bill’). This Amendment Bill attempted to offer solutions to two major constitutional problems plaguing Indian federalism: first, it increased the number of seats in the Ho
Anshul Dalmia
Aug 1
The Good, the Bad and the In-Between: Analysing the Supreme Court Judgment on Menstrual Health
On 30 January 2026, the Supreme Court of India in Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Government of India and Ors. recognised menstrual health as a constitutionally protected right under the Indian Constitution. This judgment is significant as it marks the first such concrete effort by the Supreme Court towards a constitutionally rooted rights-based approach towards menstrual health This piece analyses the judgment and argues that the strength of the Supreme Court’s approach lies in its dee
Seerat Gill
May 1
The Architecture of Erasure: How India's New Transgender Act Builds What It Claims to Dismantle (Part II)
The Architecture of Erasure To capture the imagination which the Act sets to project, it is our duty, then, to take time and ask ourselves what the nature of the polity it imagines would be. The Act provides a state that is inherently devoted to legibility. It assumes that citizens should be made intelligible to the state and, in a sense that is defined by the conceptual frame of the state; otherwise, they are not even recognized. This suggestion soaks in the bitter heritage
Aditi Anand & Anuja Chatterjee
Apr 28
The Architecture of Erasure: How India’s New Transgender Act Builds What It Claims to Dismantle (Part I)
India’s Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026 appears to have absolutely neglected the interests of the people that it is supposedly made for. The Act’s own Statement of Objects and Reasons declares that the law “was and is not to protect each and every class of persons with various gender identities.” An Act, whose title contains the phrase Protection of Rights, announces in its own explanatory text the categories of people it has chosen not to prote
Aditi Anand & Anuja Chatterjee
Apr 28
The Architecture of Harm: Intermediaries and the Constitution
Introduction The harms arising from intermediary behaviour are often public in nature, yet remain insufficiently recognised. This is largely because such harms are frequently understood merely as the aggregations of private harms. However, this framing is both inadequate and limiting, as it obscures the need for remedies that go beyond conventional privacy protection. This concern can be better understood through an analogy. The ocean exists as a natural entity populated by l
Dr Nupur Chowdhury
Apr 17
Beyond Individual Complaints: The Advantages of Positive Duties on the State in Equality and Anti-Discrimination Law
Introduction Traditionally, anti-discrimination law has relied on a complaints-led model to redress discrimination. This model requires the victim to identify an act of discrimination and take it to an adjudicatory body to attract a compensatory remedy. On the other hand, a competing emergent model for remedies is that of positive duties on the state to redress discrimination. Positive duties are proactive rather than reactive, aiming to identify and redress unlawful discrimi
Jwalika Balaji
Mar 9
Who Speaks for the Court? Attributing Accountability in Per Curiam
Introduction The history of judgment-writing and the authorship of judgments is enamoured with differing and often intersecting behavioural patterns witnessed across the globe. Broadly, the authorship format of a judgment has historically conformed to two formats – Seriatim and Per Curiam, though the terms as such came to be associated formally much later. India traditionally mirrors the seriatim format adopted from the United Kingdom, crafting judgments that curate and accou
Jappan Kaur Cheema & Nandini Garg
Feb 24
Hate Speech, Trolls and Elections: A Nefarious Nexus
Introduction Social media has been a buzzword for the Lok Sabha Elections of 2019. It had a huge role to play in determining the fate of elections in the USA which was visible after the disclosure of Cambridge Analytica Scandal.[i] The Indian elections have also been affected by social media and it has been responsible for swaying people’s opinion one way or the other. From January 1, 2019 to May 23, 2019, Twitter recorded 396 million conversations for Lok Sabha elections and
Aditya Vyas & Faiz Uddin Ahmad
Jun 23, 2019
Dichotomy between Forest Dwellers and Conservationists: Analysis of the Forest Rights Act, 2006
The Supreme Court passed an Order[i] on 13th February, 2019 (hereinafter, “the Order”) requiring the eviction of forest dwellers whose claims to forest land had been rejected by the competent authorities.[ii] The case pertains to the claims of forest dwellers to forest lands in different states viz. Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Goa etc. The Court ordered eviction of these forest dwellers. Interestingly, this Order was stayed by the Hon’ble Court on 28th February (hereinafter,
Aditya Vyas & Stuti Srivastava
Mar 12, 2019
Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018: Is it a Right to be Forgotten if it's just being Archived?
The Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018 was framed as per the directions of the Supreme Court in Puttuswasmy[i] case, amidst rising data theft, breaches, and leaks to guarantee the right to privacy and to fortify people’s rights over personal data. This article shall discuss the scope and form of the Right to be Forgotten as provided in the proposed bill in comparison to the General Data Protection Directive enacted in Europe in May 2018. Introduction The concept of ‘right to
Sanjeev Jothi
Feb 10, 2019
Transgender Bill 2018: A Half-Hearted Attempt at Complete Justice
Introduction The Transgender Community has long fought the ostracisation and ubiquitous repugnance from all sectors of the society. The National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India Judgement was a much-needed respite for the Community. Trying to follow in the footsteps of the Judiciary, the Legislature has passed the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill, 2018. This Article seeks to establish how the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Bill, 2018 is in
Smita Gupta & Paras Jain
Jan 11, 2019